Rules & asks

In writing, and never changed quietly.

A rule is what stands without being asked. An ask is what has to be. Both are kept as a record neither of you can rewrite afterwards — which is the only thing that makes either of them worth agreeing to.

Rules are grouped, written down, and announce their own changes

Rules live in groups you name — around the house, in public, about your phone — because a flat list of thirty things is a list nobody rereads. Each one is a sentence. There is no scoring, no streak and no daily tick: a rule is not a chore, it is the shape of how you already live.

What makes them different from a note in your phone is that a change is an event. Add one, remove one or reword one and the other person is told — and a reword carries the previous wording with it, because the notification is the only record of what a rule used to say.

Nothing here can be edited in the night and presented in the morning as what was always agreed.

A
The Dynamic
Alex & Blair
Alex & BlairCasey & AlexAlex & Rowan
Rules

What you’ve set out

Categories3groups
Rules9in all
New category
Etiquette
Address as Sir
Ask before leaving the house
Phone away by ten
Around the house
Kitchen clear before bed
Laundry on Sundays
Every change to these is announced — with what it used to say.
Home
2Chat
About
Menu
The rules you keepGrouped, in writing, and never changed quietly.

A rule that can be broken

For a long time a rule could be written and then had no relationship with what actually happened — the app could not tell one kept perfectly for six months from one broken every day. A breach can now be reported, and either of you can report it.

The submissive owning up is the half that makes this belong in an app like this one rather than in a demerit tracker. It is stamped as self-reported so it can never blur into having been caught, and neither side can forge which it was.

A breach is then ruled on: acknowledged, dismissed, or talked over. The third is not a softer version of the first two — it opens the chat with the rule quoted, rules on nothing, and leaves the breach waiting. A conversation is not a decision, and an app that made you pick a verdict in order to have one would get fewer honest reports.

A consequence can be attached, drawn from a list you agreed in advance, and it is written into the record as it stood — so tidying that list later cannot rewrite what was actually handed down.

Ask, and get a real answer

The things that are not standing rules get asked for. An ask is a sentence and a note; the answer is yes or no — or, far more usefully, something in between.

Yes, but be back by eleven.

Half of what a real answer looks like is a counter-offer, and with nowhere to put the “but” it used to end up in a comment while the request itself still said midnight was granted. So the Dominant can reshape an ask in the act of answering it — and only then. The original is kept and shown struck through, and the notification carries the wording that was actually agreed rather than the one that was asked for.

A yes can also have an end on it: tonight, an hour, or until a date. That, too, can only be set while granting — a yes that quietly became “yes, until Tuesday” a week later would already have been announced as an unqualified yes. Nothing sweeps it and nothing is revoked; the record simply stops overstating what was agreed, and reads “ran out” rather than “granted”.

A
The Dynamic
Alex & Blair
Alex & BlairCasey & AlexAlex & Rowan
Permissions

What they’ve asked for

Pendingwaiting 2 days

Drinks with Sam on Friday

It’s their birthday — I’d be home by midnight, collar on.

Allow Refuse
Change it, or set how long it lasts
Past decisions
Stay out past elevenGranted
A night out on the 3rdRan out
A second coffeeDenied
Always ask before
Going outBuying somethingTouching yourself
Home
2Chat
About
Menu
Ask, and get a real answerYes, no — or yes, until eleven.

The ones you ask for over and over

Standing situations are the asks that come round — going out, staying over, buying something. Each is named once, and each can carry an instruction saying what a good ask for it looks like: always give me a return time, and ask before you leave.

That instruction is shown while the ask is being written, not filed somewhere to be looked up. A standard nobody reads at the moment it applies is a document, not a standard.

Every ask and every answer stays on the record afterwards, longest-waiting first so the one that has been sitting there is the one you see. A denied or expired ask offers to ask again, prefilled — because that is the moment somebody wants to.

You do not have to think of it all yourselves

A blank rules screen on the first evening is the hardest thing about starting. There is a shared library to take from — rules, tasks and protocols other people have written and contributed — so the first version of your arrangement is something you edit rather than something you invent.

Anything taken from it becomes yours immediately: reworded, grouped and applied however you like, with no link back to where it came from. It is a starting point, not a template you are stuck inside.